Rear-Projection LCD (LcOS) or LCD flat panel?

I'm considering purchasing the Sony SXRD XBR2 but am concerned with the $300 expense of changing the lamp every 4000 hours. How much more life can I expect out of an LCD flat panel before it starts to degrade noticeably.

RP offers larger picture at lower prices. LCD flat panels are more expensive. What are your thoughts on bang for the buck versus longevity? Which offers the best long term value?

Answer:
I was in a similar situation recently, and after lots of research, I decided to go with the RP set (I chose a DLP set which was cheaper than SXRD). My recommendation for you is that if space is not a constraint and you don't have unlimited budget, go for the RP set. My reason is that cost-wise, even factoring in the cost of replacement bulbs, RP TVs are cheaper, and quality-wise, I think they are at least as good and often better than the flat panel models (e.g., for me, the screen-door effect was much more noticeable on LCD flat panels than on SXRDs or DLPs).

In terms of the life you can expect of LCD FPs, I think it's around 10 years.

One issue that discouraged me from buying a SXRD set (over a DLP set) is a green blob problem that seems to be a relatively common problem for SXRDs. I don't have a personal experience with this, but check out here for more information:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthrea...

Good luck with your TV shopping!

The answers post by the user, for information only, CeQnA.com does not guarantee the right.

  • Why can I no long access Time Warner Cable TV listings on Yahoo? Use to be so easy, not it's impossible.?
  • How do connect and watch 2 tvs without wires etc?
  • How do you operate a universal remote?
  • My video input doesn't work when I plug my dvd player/video camera into the tv, what should I do?
  • Is it possible to watch free satellite TV in China with my Supermax 9950 plus tuner?
  • Problem with my YPbPr connections?
  • Fix tv volume?
  • Mark on new tv how to get it off?
  • What hd lcd tv other than the samsung r71 range can display a pc resoulotion of 1920x1080?
  • Sony XBR TV with static sound?
  • Free scene tv if i buy one what can i monitor on it and do i obligation next to it?